Robot or manual packing: how to compare the costs
To compare a packing robot with manual packing, set the full yearly cost of the packing positions a cell takes over against the yearly cost of running the cell, and divide the investment by the difference. A TOS Robotics cell can be built for €150,000 and, at a labour cost of €32.50 per hour, has paid for itself after about 5,000 operating hours.
The cost items on both sides
| Manual side, per packing position | Robot side, per cell |
|---|---|
| Wage and employer costs, or the agency rate | Investment, including installation and start-up |
| Shift and weekend surcharges | Service and spare parts per year |
| Recruiting and training, again each season when staff changes | Energy |
| Absence and the cost of positions that stay empty | The operator who keeps an eye on the cell, usually part of one person |
| Supervision | Adding a new product or pack |
| Product that is damaged or packed wrong |
Multiply the manual side by the number of positions the cell takes over and by the hours per year the line runs. Adding a new product with programming often takes weeks of engineering. TOS Robotics teaches its cells by demonstration with the Teachbot, and in a pilot at a packer a new task was taught in one day.
The formula
Payback time in years = investment / (yearly manual cost taken over - yearly running cost of the cell)
The yearly saving grows with the hours per year the line runs and with the number of positions a cell takes over. The investment does not. The number of positions depends on the picks per minute the cell reaches on your product, compared with what one person packs per minute.
What the formula leaves out
- Availability of people. If positions cannot be filled, the comparison is not with manual packing but with lost output.
- Steady pace. A robot does not get tired, so its pace at the end of a shift is the same as at the start.
- Data. A cell with cameras can record each product it handles.
- Floor space. A compact cell can free up length along the line. The TOS Robot, the arm of TOS Robotics, is ready for deployment, with three arms on one beam above the belt. An arm built only for packing can be smaller and simpler than a general industrial arm, which is meant to lower the cost of a cell.
A calculation for your line
The answer depends on your product, your packing formats and your hours. Send us those and we make the calculation with you, including the cases where it does not pay.
Questions and answers
What does a robot packing cell of TOS Robotics cost?
A cell can be built for €150,000. At a labour cost of €32.50 per hour it has paid for itself after about 5,000 operating hours, which is less than three years.
What is easy to forget in the comparison?
On the manual side the cost of recruiting, training, absence and agency fees. On the robot side the hours per year the line really runs. A cell that runs two shifts pays back about twice as fast as the same cell on one shift.